Saving Parking Spaces in Winter

Editor's Choice Is Holding a Shoveled-Out Spot with Furniture a Do or a Don't?

Jan 30, 2009 Brett McKenzie

In many U.S. cities that see snowfall during winter months, residents who park their cars on the street often save their shoveled-out spots with furniture and cones.

When major snowfall hits, and drivers spend hours in the bitter cold digging out their cars, many feel entitled to "hold" or "save" their spot by placing personal property, such as a chair or garbage can, where their car was, so that upon returning home, they can reclaim the parking spot they so painstakingly shoveled.

However, some cities have had it with the practice of calling "dibs" on a parking space on a public city street.

Staking Dibs on a Spot May Be Illegal

In Boston, Massachusetts, the time-honored tradition of holding a shoveled-out parking space has come under city government regulation. The City of Boston states that "spacesavers®" may only be used when the city has officially declared a snow emergency, and "Any spacesavers® left in on-street parking spaces that have been shoveled out must be removed 48 hours after a snow emergency has ended."

Chicago, Illinois, has decided that Streets & Sanitation workers will begin to remove items holding parking spaces if residents won't. According to the Chicago Tribune, "The practice is technically against the law because it's an obstruction of the public way, Streets and Sanitation spokesman Matt Smith said. But the department uses common sense in allowing the informal justice of dibs to hold sway in the side streets for a few days after major snowstorms."

Items Commonly Used to Hold Spots

The big orange cone appears to be the preferred item of choice for space-saving, but a Boston.com photo gallery illustrates that people will go to great lengths to find items to save their spot.

Items spotted in Boston and Chicago include:

  • Garbage cans
  • Paint buckets
  • Chairs and benches (folding, rocking, computer chairs... even old armchairs!)
  • Children's playthings
  • Laundry hampers
  • Milk crates
  • Tables
  • Bottles of laundry detergent
  • Shovels
  • Clothesracks
  • Shopping carts

Conflicting Views on Fairness

Advocates of saving spaces argue that the person who shoveled the spot is entitled to it, but opponents maintain that the public streets are city—not private—property. In a Boston.com online poll, the majority of respondents (42%) said that parking spaces are "public property, no one has the right to claim it." On the other end of the spectrum, 7% of respondents said that shoveling out a spot meant they could claim it "indefinitely."

Things to Consider Before You Save Your Spot

  1. Is the practice legal in your city or town? Check your city or town web site or call a local official or police station to check to avoid any fines associated with the practice.
  2. Consider your neighbors: chances are, if this isn't a practice they participate in, they'll be annoyed. Also, if your neighbors have elderly or handicapped visitors, you could be inconveniencing someone who needs the spot a lot more than you do.
  3. Is the item you're planning to use something you wouldn't mind losing? Angry neighbors or city street and sanitation workers may remove the item, throw it out, or even steal it. Don't use your favorite folding chair.
  4. Is there a better parking option? Perhaps you can rent a garage spot in the winter to spare yourself the pain of shoveling and avoid the inter-neighborhood tensions that can arise.

The copyright of the article Saving Parking Spaces in Winter in Home Management is owned by Brett McKenzie. Permission to republish Saving Parking Spaces in Winter in print or online must be granted by the author in writing.
What do you think about this article?

NOTE: Because you are not a Suite101 member, your comment will be moderated before it is viewable.
post your comment
What is 6+5?

Comments

Jan 29, 2009 1:58 PM
Guest :
I'd say it's a do. if you shovel it, you get it. I don't think indefinitely, but most certainly a week after the storm sounds reasonable.
I think anyone that's had to shovel their car out after the snow plow's come by would agree.
Jan 29, 2009 4:20 PM
Guest :
You totally get to keep your spot. It has been an unwritten rule in Chicago for decades.

But part of the pact has always been that if you live next to elderly or handicapped people (add single moms these days) and their car is buried, you shovel their spot, too. Anybody that saves themselves but leaves an old lady stranded in her house is getting their lawn chair tossed.
Jan 30, 2009 1:07 AM
Mia Carter :
It may be prohibited in some cities to claim spots, but that doesn't stop anyone. And with the social repercussions, you'd be nuts to take another person's spot. Park in a claimed spot in some parts of Southie (Boston) you can expect to come back to a very different car from the one you parked there - deflated tires, scratched paint, motor oil on the windshield, broken windows, broken wipers. You name it.
In these older neighborhoods, tradition rules. Most people probably park in another person's spot once; that's all it takes to learn a lesson. And rightfully so - if you've ever shoveled out a parking spot, you know how much hard work it is!
Jan 30, 2009 1:57 PM
Thomas Alan Gray :
I had never heard of this "dibs" thing. Wherever I have lived in Alberta, the attitude has been that the street in front of your home is where you and your guests may park. If someone else parks there for a while, nobody minds too much--as long as they're not blocking a driveway--and vandalism of the type described above is shocking.

But then, Canadians are famous for their courtesy.
Feb 1, 2009 6:02 PM
Guest :
this is complete BS. Not only is damaging a vehicle parked in 'your' spot vandalism, pure and simple, resident 'furniture' in the street is ugly and makes the beautiful chicago neighborhoods ugly and strewn with garbage. This practice has to stop.
May 4, 2009 10:20 AM
Guest :
"Saving" parking spaces? Seriously? If you don't want someone parking legally on the street, get a freakin house with a driveway! If I catch anyone vandalizing my car if I park on a public street, I would use their head as a punching bag!
May 10, 2009 2:51 PM
Guest :
I say keep the snow, in a decent size pile nearby, move your car, bury the spot, poor water, that way, someone else has to EARN it. See how the city likes that. Keep some salt with you though.
Jul 31, 2009 11:36 AM
Guest :
Saving spots is a tired practice. "Oh, it's so hard to shovel out a spot." Give me a break. I've seen some of Chicago's worst winters, and I'm not such a cry baby about it. Shoveling is a fact of life, and to take claim over something to which you have no right isn't going to make it any better. Get over yourselves.
8 Comments